top of page

How do you say no in dog language!

Writer: Sarah at Barkshire Dog Training
Sarah at Barkshire Dog Training
Nov 1
7 min read

Summary

Dogs don’t understand the word “no”. They respond to your tone of voice and body language, which is often angry, worried or frustrated in the moment. Instead of saying no, try the 3 Question Check: what did your dog do, did they have access to something they shouldn’t, and what could you teach them to do instead?

Why do we use no?

When we start working together, clients complete a questionnaire to help me understand their goals, daily routines and how things are going. One of the questions I ask is, “How do you correct your dog when they do something you don’t want them to, or don’t like?”


About 90% of the answers share that us humans use “no”, sometimes in a stern voice, sometimes loudly!


Most of us use the word “no” every day and assume our dogs understand it. They don’t, at least not as a word. What they respond to is the tone. When we say no, we are rarely calm. We are cross, worried or frustrated, because the sock is in their mouth, the chicken is off the side or the puppy has just gone for your toes. That emotion comes through in our voice and in our body, and that is what our dogs pick up on.


So here is what I recommend instead. Try not using “no” at all, and use what I call the 3 Question Check. It works for almost any behaviour, not just when you want to say no.

Spaniel brown and tan being told off a finger being waved
Your dog is not naughty


1. What did your dog do that made you want to say no?

Start by getting clear on what actually happened. Not “he was naughty”, but what exactly did he do? Jumped up at a visitor? Picked up a shoe? Stole food from the counter? Barked at the window?

Once you can name the behaviour, you can start to work out why it happened, and that is where we find the solution.


2. Did they have access to something they shouldn’t?

If the answer is yes, then I am going to gently say that is our fault, not theirs.

I say it kindly, because I have done it too. The shoes by the front door, the bin that opens easily, treats in a jacket pocket left at nose height, the lunch left on the edge of the table. Dogs are curious. They explore with their mouths and their noses, and if something is within reach and smells interesting, it is going to get investigated.


That is not naughtiness. That is a dog being a dog. The good news is that it is the easiest thing to fix. A baby gate, a closed door, a bin with a lid or a quick tidy before the kids come home removes the opportunity before it ever turns into a problem.


When Davey came to live with us, we were not as vigilant in the first few weeks, because Archie had been brilliant and never went for food left out on the side. One day we left some butter in its wrapper on the counter to use for baking later. When we got home, neither of us could work out what had happened. There was no evidence, nothing disturbed on the counter and no wrapper to be found. Twenty-four hours later, I won’t go into the details, but nature did its thing and we worked it out. It was not Davey’s fault. It was ours, for leaving it too close to the edge. We never left things within reach again, and thankfully Davey never repeated it. We were very lucky, as he had no ill effects other than a slightly upset tummy.


3. What else could you have done?

This is the question that changes things. If you are shouting no, your dog still does not know what you would like them to do instead. So give them an answer.


  • Teach a drop or a swap. If your dog picks up something they shouldn’t, a swap for a treat or a toy turns a game of chase into an easy trade. Practise it with boring things first, so it works when it really matters.


  • Scatter some treats. If your dog is jumping up, throwing a handful of treats on the floor gives them somewhere better to put their nose and all four paws. It also gives you a moment to reset.


  • Give them something to do. A chew, a lick mat or a sniffy game for a dog who is pestering you is often enough.


  • Spot those glimmers and reward what you want. Reward the sit, the settle, the four paws on the floor. Dogs repeat what works.


This takes a bit of planning, which is exactly the point. Our dogs are not naughty on purpose. They do not wake up and think, how can I annoy my owner today? It is usually a mix of our lack of planning and their curiosity that creates the opportunity for something to happen, and that makes us shout.


What your dog is doing

Instead of “no”

Try this

Jumping up at visitors

Stay calm and move away

Scatter treats on the floor, then ask for a sit and reward four paws on the ground

Picking up a sock or shoe

Don’t chase

Swap for a treat or a toy, then put the item away

Stealing from the counter

Don’t shout

Clear the counter, use a gate or door, and reward them for settling on a mat

Chewing the furniture

Interrupt calmly

Offer a chew, and give them a safer place to be when you can’t watch

Barking at the window

Don’t shout over it

Reduce the view, call them away and reward quiet


What if “no” just slips out?

It will, and that is okay. We are all human, and a quick “oi!” when your puppy heads for the road is not going to ruin anything. The goal is not to be perfect. It is to notice, take a breath, and then show your dog what to do next. The more you plan, the less you will need it.


Key takeaway

If you take one thing away, let it be this: your dog is not trying to wind you up. They are curious, they are learning, and they are relying on you to set things up so it is easy for them to get it right.

Run the 3 Question Check: ask what happened, check whether they had access, and think about what you could have done instead. That is how you say no in dog language, and it works far better than raising your voice.


Frequently asked questions


What is the 3 Question Check?

It is a quick way to work out what is going on when your dog does something you don’t like, before you reach for “no”. Ask what your dog actually did, whether they had access to something they shouldn’t, and what else you could have done, such as teaching a drop or a swap. It turns frustration into curiosity, and that is where change starts.


What should I say instead of no to my dog?

Use a calm, clear cue your dog already knows, such as “drop”, “leave it”, “this way” or “sit”, then reward them for getting it right. If they don’t know a cue yet, that becomes your training plan: teach it when things are calm, using something they really like as the reward. Showing your dog what to do works far better than a louder no.


Does my dog understand the word no?

Not as a word. Dogs learn what words mean through repetition and what happens afterwards. Most of the time, they are reading your tone of voice and body language, which is often cross, worried or frustrated. That is why a calm, clear cue they have been taught works far better.


Why does my dog ignore me when I say no?

Because “no” does not tell them what to do instead. It also tends to be said when you are already stressed, so it can become background noise, or even part of the game. Give your dog a cue they know and a reward for doing it, and you will see the difference.


Is my dog being naughty on purpose?

Almost never. Dogs do not plan to annoy us. They are curious, they explore with their mouths and noses, and they repeat what works. Most “naughty” behaviour is a dog being a dog in a house that was not set up for them.


How do I correct my dog without shouting?

Think about guiding rather than correcting. Work out what happened, remove the opportunity if you can, and show your dog what you would like instead, such as a swap, a scatter of treats or a settle on their mat. Reward the behaviour you want and plan ahead so the same situation does not keep happening. Shouting adds stress and excitement without teaching your dog anything.


How do I stop my dog jumping up without saying no?

Stay calm and avoid giving attention while they are jumping, then give them something better to do. Scatter a handful of treats on the floor, or ask for a sit and reward four paws on the ground. Practise it when it is quiet, so it is easier when visitors arrive.


What is a drop or a swap?

It is teaching your dog to let go of something in exchange for something they like even more, such as a treat or a toy. Start with boring items so your dog learns that giving things up is a good deal. Never chase them, as that turns it into a game.


What should I do if my dog has something dangerous?

Stay calm, don’t chase and don’t shout. Swap for something tasty if you can, and take the item away. If they have swallowed something that could be harmful, such as chocolate, grapes, raisins or anything sharp, ring your vet straight away or call Animal Poison Line on 01202 509000 (charges apply). Not sure what is poisonous? Watch my live with Animal Poison Line to find out more.



Is it ever okay to say no to my dog?

If it slips out in an emergency, that is human and it is fine. What matters is what happens next. Take a breath, show your dog what to do instead, and use the moment to plan so it happens less often.


Want some help with this?

If you find yourself saying no all day long, it is worth looking at the whole picture rather than guessing. I can help you work out what is happening in your home, put a plan in place and feel confident about what to do next. A short call is all it takes to start the conversation. No pressure, no commitment, just a chat.



Not quite ready for that? Sign up to my newsletter instead. I write every week about the real life things that come up with dogs.


About the author: I am Sarah, a dog trainer based in Reading, Berkshire, and for more than five years I’ve been helping families with puppies and everyday behaviour through tailored programmes. Qualified wtih IMDT, Simone Meuller and The Dog Trainer School.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page